History as a (Leftist) Weapon
Gail Jarvis
Gail Jarvis
There
is a tendency for each generation to assume its opinions are the
ultimate correct opinions. But each generation’s beliefs are typically
modified by succeeding generations. Unfortunately, societal structures
are sometimes altered based on contemporary notions that lose credence
over time. This is the case with Social Justice Warriors in this
generation. They demand that whatever doesn’t suit present-day social
theories must be “eliminated.”
One of the justifications for this cultural cleansing
is this generation’s historical interpretation of the War Between the
States (WBTS). Some assume that this current version – moral opposition
to slavery caused the North to fight the South – has a long-standing
consensus among historians. But this is only one of countless
interpretations historians have produced over the years. Various
historians, writing at different times and places, have created diverse
interpretations of the WBTS. These history reinterpretations are often
influenced by major events occurring in later generations.
One of these major events was World War I. This war
was broadly viewed as “futile” – not only unnecessary, but instigated by
a “bungling generation.” Like the WBTS, historians put forth various
causes for this fruitless World War. It was supposed to be the war to
end all wars, but it created more problems than it solved. The severe
measures that the Treaty of Versailles imposed on Germany soon led to
WWII. Many historians were influenced by this problematic war which made
them skeptical of the purposes and relevance of the WBTS. Some decided
that, like WWI, the WBTS could have been avoided. They also minimized
the importance of slavery as a cause of the War and maintained that the
basic conflict was economics.
At the other extreme was WWII. This war was deemed
necessary as the ruthless Nazi Party must be stopped. The immense
destruction of European cites had to be halted. Also the inhumane
treatment and mass executions of those incarcerated in concentration
camps – Communists, Socialists, Jews, and other “enemies of the state”
had to be ended. WWII caused many historians to rethink the WBTS. These
historians again made slavery an essential cause of the WBTS . They also
maintained that the War was necessary because it ended slavery and
saved the Union.
http://www.silverbearcafe.com/private/09.18/weapon.html
No comments:
Post a Comment