Conflict is like everything else –
people get labels assigned to them based on their supposed political
party, even though those parties do not represent the best interests of
their base. Therefore, in the light of the meltdown over Palestine, and
the number of Jewish-loving born again Christians, especially in the
United States, it is high time to take a closer look at what the roots
of the current violence is—not an easy undertaking.
Most pundits and politicians are so
involved in discussing the political and funding side of the
Arab-Israeli conflict that they are unwilling to accept that its root
cause is land and not religion. It is like beating a drum—and Trump
claims that he has merely accepted what was already a reality, as
Jerusalem is functionally the capital of Israel.
Not so simple
I am reminded of one of my former
graduate students in academic writing, who wanted to write a paper on
the Arab-Israeli Conflict and was surprised when I told her that the
topic was too large. I explained that it would keep her busy for the
rest of her life, and how she needed to find something more focused to
get her assignment done.
Naively, the young girl, from a country
with its own rich history of Jewish culture and community, asked me…
“then what are they fighting about.”
I told her the conflict was not about
religion, as Jews, Arabs and Christians were all able to live
side-by-side, as it was part of [our] religion to get along. It was not
until the UN decided to decant the remnant of Jews in Europe to an
artificial state it had set up itself, based on the mess the British had
left in their Palestine Mandate, that the trouble had begun. “It is all
over land and who has the most right to it.”
This view may be an oversimplification,
but it gets to the crux of the matter. Alan Dowty, Professor of
Government and International Studies and Fellow of the Joan B. Kroc
Institute for International Peace Studies at the University of Notre
Dame, confirms this: “The core of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is
the claim of two peoples to the same piece of land.”
However, the more recent standoff over
the rights of Palestinians is rooted in new forms of nationalism which
have developed simply because the attitude of the rest of the world has
encouraged the conflict to frame itself in these terms. Combined with
so-called security walls, land grabs and foreign interventions, these
artificial nationalisms of the Macedonian type complicate any
potentially lasting solution, whether it be grating equal rights in the
UN-created State of Israel for all citizens, or adopting the two state
solution envisioned in various peace accords, such as the Camp David
Agreement, Oslo Agreement, Wye Plantation etcetera.
https://journal-neo.org/2018/09/01/trump-and-understanding-the-root-causes-of-violence-in-palestine-israel/
https://journal-neo.org/2018/09/01/trump-and-understanding-the-root-causes-of-violence-in-palestine-israel/
https://journal-neo.org/2018/09/01/trump-and-understanding-the-root-causes-of-violence-in-palestine-israel/
No comments:
Post a Comment