the joos are........ fill in the blank;
When should we call a spade a spade? That is, when should the niceties and the euphemisms end, and the straight truth be told? This, of course, is a judgement call, to be decided based on how urgent and pressing the matter at hand is, and also on the consequences of the blunt truth versus a more conventional, polite approach. Few people enjoy being deliberately provocative, but when soft, accommodating language fails to have its intended effect, then other, stronger, more explicit words are called for.
When it comes to Israel, Palestine, and the Jewish Lobby generally, I think the time has come for straight talk. For example, for years, we were told that one could never utter the phrase “the Jews” because, well, it just…wasn’t…done. To refer to “the Jews” somehow recalled the bad old days of pogroms, expulsions, and various other nasty deeds inflicted on an innocent Jewish people. “The Jews” referred to a demonized, faceless mass that was always the scapegoat, always unjustly persecuted; the phrase was previously uttered only by the most vehement anti-Semites, and since no one wants to be called an anti-Semite today, one could simply not use the dreaded phrase.
If one pressed the issue, one was likely told more explicitly that the phrase “the Jews” lumped all Jews into a single category, and since there is a vast array of views and opinions among Jewish people, that it was simply incorrect to group them all together like that—in essence, it was technically wrong to use such a phrase. If one was inclined to say something like “the Jews are rich” or “the Jews are obnoxious” or “the Jews are powerful,” this was technically incorrect because, obviously, not all Jews are rich, or obnoxious, or powerful. And since any such discussion of the form “the Jews are X” or “the Jews do X” was technically false, that one should never use the phrase. Only a “bad person” would persist in using such belligerent, antagonistic, and offensive language..........more.........
No comments:
Post a Comment